Reprinted with permission from 
Vintage Fashion & Costume Jewelry
P.O Box 265
Glen Oaks, NY 11004
and the author

Written by Kathy Flood for The Fall 2003 edition of Vintage Fashion & Costume Jewelry

Brass Santa Claus charm facing right.    Brass Christmas Tree Motif   Brass Santa Claus charm facing left. 

Help prevent forest mires by selecting only the Christmas tree species with highest personal appeal.

Written by Kathy Flood 

Most costume jewelry collectors who specialize in the abundant Christmas tree pin motif eventually cut back their overgrown forests to signed-only specimens. It’s the simplest method of deforestation, but there are much better ways to go. Why eliminate such pleasures as the Laguna Glass Mosaic, the Mylu Watermelon Rivoli, the Vero Funny Face or Juliana’s Hark the Halo just because no one bothered to hang a name on the back bough? Rather than weed out the wordless works of art from your woods, better to specialize in acres that have most-meaning and appeal for you. There are 100 ways to pine when designing a Niche Noel. Here are five.

A Christmas Comedy

The Seinfeld, DeGeneres and Chris Rock of Christmas tree pin companies are Jonette, Lianna and Vero. Each company created its share of beautiful Christmas tree pins, but they produced the funniest as well. Their amusing arbors make the holidays humorous and utterly charming. Funny? J.J.’s cat couple (next page) look lovingly at a fish-trimmed tannenbaum. They also do a frog in Kringle Kap dragging a pine back to his lylypad. Lia has a merry mouser wearing a tree as a dress, and the goofy moose from Lianna peeks out from behind a lush Yuletide fir. Vero created a Christmas tree with a face that makes it look like a native of Oz. A walking pine from Vero features Santa’s red-dressed appendages sticking out.  And one of the most sought after comic conifers is  Jonette’s google-eyed vintage tree with dancing pupils (above). It’s to laugh. Because Comedy Christmas isn’t a vast vintage niche (though it grows every year in contemporary terms), it’s a good one to combine with something like Promotional-Advertising-Character Trees, which are often amusing as well (Disney’s Mickey Mouse trees, Warner Bros.’ Tweetie trees, etc.)

Happy Holiday Plastic and Glass

Isn’t it ironic: Just as Bakelite can beat out gold and diamonds at auction, some of the most valuable and coveted Christmas tree pins are also made of glass or plastic. A collector who focuses on celluloid, acrylic, resins, Catalin or glass will be buying some of the most expensive trees on the market, as well as the cheapest. Vintage celluloid Christmas tree pins are the oldest there are, from the 1930s, and can be harvested for $5. Moving along the price and chronology spectrum collectors find such prized pines as the most-wanted Eisenberg (block-letter) crystal cone of 1975 (Karl Eisenberg believes it was a bust because it flip-flopped from overweight on lapels) and the art-moderne Laguna, christened the Stained Glass Tree (both, next page). Lea Stein’s French acetate firs come in cool color patterns. Both the Schultzes and the Lains are now well-known for the Bakelite and Catalin Creations trees, and others are getting in on the plastics act too, using everything from Lucite to Fifties thermoplastic beads. More plastics? Mod Pod trees (next page) from two New York artists first popped up in Vogue ages ago and have become all the rage. If you want to graduate up to a new degree of collecting, plastic and glass are two words for you.

Artists Climbing Trees

Christmas tree pins designed as one-of-a-kind or limited editions by talented artists make a grand nche to collect. Artists use any and every medium, from Lucite to wood, rhinestones to paper, plastic to metal. Bottom line: they can make great things out of nothing. I found vintage "Philadelphia" beads (but plastic, not Bakelite) and thought they’d make a terrific Xmas tree. I tried to design something myself and the result was so sad, I sent the beads on to jewelry artist Sheryl Hamilton at the Family Jools and she smartly confected an amazing arbor, a Philadelphia fir that is a simple classic (page 12). Another artist, Cheryl Empson (aka eBay’s LadyLucite), carved a stunning tree using the material she employs for her button artworks (page 12): vintage Lucite. (Her father was a Lucite master.) Her vintage dyes render ravishing hues.

A Christmas tree pin work of art that’s a masterpiece of marquetry is composed of intricately inlaid wood. Or consider the handiwork of Emilia Castillo, the Mexican artist with a famous pedigree and a way with metal. Her tree clip overleaf is a 1997 design and may have been sold at Neiman-Marcus. Suzi Chauvet makes merry with paper designs (left) collectors have dug for years. And Stefanie Somers’ Christmas collection is a riot of colors, shapes and textures in her inimitable signature look of high-quality collage.

When I designed the tree in 1998 I thought Picasso might have painted if he were a jollier fellow, a Matisse tree was also part of that "great Artists" group. Here, at last (see cover) is Henri’s holiday arbre, dubbed the Matreese (to go along with the Pinecasso), brought to life by Paul Verrecchia.

Is there anything more versatile than a Christmas tree in terms of design possibilities?

The Shapes of Christmas Past & Present

Christmas tree pins come in every shape...including round. Collections could be composed of only oddly shaped pines and still grow wild. Take the holiday topiary tree and the partridge-in-pear tree (left and cover), for instance. These are jolly holiday brooches with a twist. Cadoro trees are king of the forest in this niche, with Yuletide pear trees done as both topiary and typically shaped saplings. Their lavishly enameled trees, manufactured by Alfeo Verrecchia’s company, are fervently collected because of the enamel’s rich colors and quality casting. (Who know exactly how many they created? When I studied the Neiman-Marcus catalog archives, there was a new tree every year back then.) Alfeo’s son, Paul, who founded Lianna, also made great pear trees and topiaries (next page). Cartier created the most famous topiary of all, in 1928, with precious gems. Two other well-known pear trees are by Bettina von Walhof and Kirks Folly.

We’ll Take Our Trees Rare, Thanks

You could take the high road and hunt in the deepest section of the forest, the one where the rare firs frolic. That would keep your forest small and select: Juliana, Schiaparelli, Haskell, Hermes, Har; the oldest Swarovskis, two Eisenbergs; incredibly scarce Hollycraft and Weiss trees, Trifari "poured glass" mosaic, Marie Ferra, the Yosca Snow Cone tree, vintage sterling Danecraft, early Judith Jack trees, and so many more maddening scarcities. You simply never know: A Jonette just popped up I had never seen before, and I had to borrow the J.J. google-eyed tree from Cathy Gordon because I don’t have one. You don’t typically think of Jonettes as rare, yet there certainly are some. Others I didn’t see till after 10 years of looking: Caviness, an unusual Kramer, funky Originals by Robert, offbeat

Sandors and Castlecliffs

There are infinite ways to grow a manageable jewelry forest, from choosing only trees with candles to ones with a message...or music...or light-up mechanisms. If you love Hattie Carnegie, harvest only her trees along with your other HC pieces.

And just think: You could even grow a niche collection of fakes. That way, all those phonies marked KJL or Kenneth Lane could star in your forest...and you won’t have to feel quite so bad about being duped when you discover the only Xmas tree Ken Lane ever created was the one marked FM, for the Franklin Mint.


If this article has put you in the mood for a little Christmas shopping, try clicking here  
for an article to put you over the top!

Bah humbug ... and a Merry Christmas!

Photo gallery of Christmas Tree Pins

All Guyot Products are now part of 
Salvadore Tool & Findings

  (c) 2003-2018 Guyot Brothers Co Inc,  A jewelry findings manufacturer